Log In / Join Now

Unexpected Rewards from Old Bottles

It doesn't always require a classic vintage, just a good one
Three bottles from deep in the cellar proved worth the wait.
Photo by: Harvey Steiman
Three bottles from deep in the cellar proved worth the wait.

Posted: Dec 11, 2017 2:35pm ET

"Now that Wine Spectator has made it safe to drink Merlot again," Mark Tarlov joked as he opened a valise before lunch in San Francisco, "I thought we could try this." He extracted a 36-year-old bottle of Duckhorn Merlot Napa Valley Three Palms Vineyard 1981 from the bag.

The Duckhorn Merlot Napa Valley Three Palms Vineyard 2014, our 2017 Wine of the Year, put the lie to a longstanding disdain among snobby wine drinkers who found Merlot no longer as appealing as other grapes. In particular Pinot Noir, the specialty grape variety of Tarlov's Chapter 24 winery in Oregon.

His bottle looked a little dusty, having lain untouched in his personal cellar since 1984. With a fill nearly touching the cork, it looked promising. The first sniff revealed a mix of earthy loam, dried herbs and white pepper, the first sip a nice hint of cherry, but it finished with an unfortunate sharpness.

"We can always open the Burgundy I brought instead," he sighed. But five minutes later, things improved. The Merlot's fruit was more prominent, the texture took on a polished sheen. We kept sipping at it. It got better with every tick of the clock, and by the third glass it was completely charming. The aroma and flavor profile extended to currant, fresh mint and savory spices, and the finish broadened nicely against a welcome transparency.

Not a particularly great vintage, 1981 produced small quantities of pleasant reds in Napa. Only the fourth year bottled from this vineyard in the warm northern corner of Napa Valley, this was clearly a step up from that, well worth the patience.

On successive evenings, two more old bottles came up unexpectedly great.

Recalling a recent recommendation from a sommelier at a fine Indian restaurant to match older reds to foods with prominent Indian spices, I pulled out my last bottle of Ceretto Barolo Brunate Bricco Rocche 1993, another nice vintage not expected to age spectacularly. But this wine struck a delicate balance of savory, earthy notes against classic Barolo rose petal. The strawberry and raspberry notes shone. Tannins had softened into a velvety burr. The finish refused to quit. The wine sensationally completed tandoori lamb and shrimp in a spicy spinach sauce, and vice versa.

Finally, for a chicken I roasted for my wife's birthday, I opened a long-cellared bottle of Beringer Cabernet Sauvignon Private Reserve Napa Valley Lemmon-Chabot Vineyard 1980, another good but unspectacular vintage for Napa. This vineyard, outside St. Helena on the east side of the valley, has always been a key element in the winery's private reserve bottlings. This single-vineyard bottle was absolutely gorgeous from first sip—generous, expansive but not weighty, plush and silky in texture, vibrant with black cherry, red plum and blueberry flavors. The finish rolled on and on. Great with the spatchcocked chicken, baked potatoes and long-cooked carrots.

Keeping wines for 24, 36 or 37 years guarantees nothing, of course. I usually prefer to drink wines on their way up because corks can fail, bottle variation can rob wines of their charm, and wines can simply head down a fading slope. Frankly it's a bonus when three straight old bottles emerge this good. What makes it worth leaving a few bottles alone for a decade or three? A wine can slowly develop into something more graceful and complex. When it does, it can deliver big smiles.

Jonathan Lawrence
Midwest —  December 11, 2017 6:53pm ET
Bottle variation? Can you clarify this? What causes it? How often is it a problem?
Tom Miller
Birmingham, AL —  December 20, 2017 4:57pm ET
Harvey, I am glad to hear that your 1980 Beringer Lemmon-Chabot Cab was holding up nicely. That was one of my all time "special wines" back in the day so kudos to you and your cellar...and your wife on her birthday.
Harvey Steiman
San Francisco —  January 3, 2018 2:53am ET
Sorry to be so late responding, Jonathan. The alert for your comment only reached me today.

Bottle variation is a catch-all term for the differences—sometimes subtle, sometimes dramatic—from one bottle to another of a given wine. As the wine ages, these differences magnify. Some corks let in a bit more air than others, with little effect in the first year but much greater impact after several years. Differences in temperature also affect wines, and storage in different vats before bottling can be a factor. Sometimes the culprit is low levels of TCA or other unwelcome microbes in the cork or on the inside of the bottle before it's closed.

All those things, not just cork taint, have led many in the wine field to prefer other closures, especially twist-offs.

Would you like to comment? Want to join or start a discussion?

Become a WineSpectator.com member and you can!
To protect the quality of our conversations, only members may submit comments. Member benefits include access to more than 315,000 reviews in our Wine Ratings Search; a first look at ratings in our Insider, Advance and Tasting Highlights; Value Wines; the Personal Wine List/My Cellar tool, hundreds of wine-friendly recipes and more.

WineRatings+ app: Download now for 365,000+ ratings.