Log In / Join Now

Will Chianti Classico’s Gran Selezione Designation Guarantee Quality?

The new Gran Selezione designation promises stricter quality standards. At Agricola San Felice, the new bottling is the result of years of research
Photo by: David Yellen

Posted: Apr 16, 2014 4:00pm ET

The Consorzio of Chianti Classico introduced its new designation, Gran Selezione, in 2013. It represents the pinnacle of a quality pyramid whose base comprises the Chianti Classico annate and mid-tier riserva categories. The goal is to have stricter standards to drive quality and inspire consumer confidence in the wines of Chianti Classico. The new category is projected to represent about 10 percent of the Chianti Classico production.

Currently, there is a lot of confusion about Chianti. It can be made from a large area in central Tuscany and can sell for anywhere from $10 to $200 a bottle.

Chianti Classico Gran Selezione must be made from estate-grown grapes of a single vineyard (or selection of the estate's best parcels) and the aging requirements are longer than those of riserva, 30 months vs. 24 months, including three months in bottle. Sangiovese must make up at least 80 percent of the blend, with other approved grape varieties allowed by the Denominazione di Origine Controllata e Garantita (DOCG).

The Gran Selezione wines are also subject to a panel tasting along with chemical and physical analyses by authorized labs.

This all sounds fine, in theory. Now, the first Gran Selezione wines are about to be released. According to Silvia Fiorentini of the Chianti Classico Consorzio, 47 wines have been approved to date, with a 10 percent fail rate of the overall submissions.

My first look at the new premium category was San Felice's Chianti Classico Il Grigio Gran Selezione 2010. Winemaker Leonardo Bellaccini came by Wine Spectator's New York office with San Felice president Mario Cuccia and general manager Davide Profeti with the estate's 2010 vintage.

Since Bellaccini joined San Felice in 1984, the estate embarked on viticultural research in conjunction with the University of Florence. Much of that work has been genetic research of the indigenous grape varieties of Tuscany. There are more than 5 acres in San Felice's Vitiarium, a "museum" of vines planted to 270 different grapes.

Bellaccini and his colleagues saw an opportunity to combine these two decades of research and work in San Felice's nearly 350 acres of vineyards with the new Gran Selezione designation. "We wanted to show this was a project we had before and Gran Selezione gave us an opportunity to use it," he said.

In addition to using the best plots of Sangiovese (Chiesamonti, Colti and Pianaccio) and the oldest vines, what's interesting about San Felice's new wine is the other grapes in the blend. Sangiovese, at 80 percent, meets the regulatory minimum, while the remaining 20 percent includes Cilegiolo and Malvasia Nera (for aromas and fruit), Abrusco (for color), Pugnitello (for structure) and Mazzese (for spice). These are all indigenous Tuscan grapes developed from the Vitiarium.

The San Felice Chianti Classico Il Grigio Gran Selezione 2010 is a very aromatic red, offering deep cherry, licorice and hints of leather and spice. Its rich, sweet fruit is balanced by vibrant acidity, while the cherry, leather, tobacco and spice flavors persist on the long finish.

It saw 20 to 25 days of maceration on the skins, initially with pumping over, then punching down the cap for the last two weeks. Half the wine was aged in 9,000- to 10,000-liter casks and the other half in 500-liter tonneaux and barriques. About 10 to 15 percent of the barriques were new. After two years in wood, it was blended and bottled, where it rested for six months.

San Felice also continues to make its Chianti Classico Il Grigio Riserva, which is 100 percent Sangiovese. This may be confusing, with two Il Grigios on the market, so be sure to look for the Gran Selezione designation on the label.

Nonetheless, if San Felice's new entry into the Chianti Classico Gran Selezione designation is any indication, this could be an exciting new era for Tuscany's historic region.

During Vinitaly 2014 this past week, the annual Italian wine fair, plus subsequent visits to Tuscany, I have tasted about a half-dozen Gran Selezione wines, including Castello di Meleto 2010, Mazzei Castello di Fonterutoli 2010 and Il Molino di Grace Il Margone 2010. Giovanni Manetti of Fontodi also told me what was formerly the estate's Vigna del Sorbo Riserva will become the Gran Selezione.

There appears to be good support from the producers. Now it's the consumers' turn to buy into the new Gran Selezione concept.

Eric Campos
Canada —  April 15, 2014 7:12pm ET
Bruce, can you expand on the 'quality' components of the new designation? you can already find plenty of comments regarding the panel evaluations. Reading Mitch Frank's article from last year, this does not sound like a baby step toward Burgundian classification, but rather like a way to mimic the Bordeaux system that enables large estates to cherry-pick their "grand vin" regardless of terroir or character predictability for the consumer.
Jim Mason
St. John's, Canada —  April 20, 2014 4:25pm ET
Well it appears that greater terroir will be expressed by the use of single vineyard grapes and the character predictability by the minimum 80% Sanviovese. But a lot of CC Riservas already use 80% or more Sangiovese and age their wines for longer than the 24month minimum. So this looks to be a way to wring a few extra dollars from consumers with an added classification level, not unlike the Gran Reservas of Spain. And perhaps to offer a product that would compete more effectively with that other great Tuscan wine, Brunello.
Bruce Sanderson
New York, NY —  April 22, 2014 12:16pm ET
Eric, the new designation is first and foremost a guarantee that the consumer is buying an estate wine, as opposed to a wine that was purchased in bulk, possibly blended with other wines from the greater Chianti (not Classico) area and bottled without any geographical or terroir link.

In terms of quality, the permitted yields are no different than the annata or riserva levels, however the "dry extract" (a measure of the non-volatile solids in a wine, including polyphenols) is slightly higher, suggesting a higher percentage of tannins, though not necessarily a guarantee of higher quality.

You are correct that it is not a classification in the Burgundian sense, but rather an "estate selection." There are producers in favor of a further stop toward designating geographical areas, such as Radda or Gaiole to define styles.

It also appears that many of the new Gran Selezione entries are not new wines at all, but estate wines that will now carry the new designation. As always, it is best to seek out reliable producers with strong track records.

Would you like to comment? Want to join or start a discussion?

Become a WineSpectator.com member and you can!
To protect the quality of our conversations, only members may submit comments. Member benefits include access to more than 315,000 reviews in our Wine Ratings Search; a first look at ratings in our Insider, Advance and Tasting Highlights; Value Wines; the Personal Wine List/My Cellar tool, hundreds of wine-friendly recipes and more.

WineRatings+ app: Download now for 365,000+ ratings.