Log In / Join Now

Off to Bordeaux

Dipping my toe in the water by tasting 450 wines
Photo by: David Yellen

Posted: Dec 10, 2010 3:00pm ET

No sooner was I back from my visit to the Southern Rhône and nearly over my jetlag, and it was time to head back again, this time for a 15-day jaunt through Bordeaux, my first official tour through the region since assuming coverage at the end of his past summer.

Those of you who follow along here know that I'm deeply immersed in the Rhône. And the Rhône of course has Valrhona chocolate, so getting presents to assuage my daughters after being away for so long is easy. As for Bordeaux, madeleines don't keep as well as a box of chocolate, so I'll have to come up with something else. Hopefully they're not getting used to my being away.

Of course, a first-time visit wouldn't be complete without a little travel nightmare. My flight out of New York was delayed four hours, so I missed my connection in Paris, then had to dash for the next one. That flight of course, wound up being delayed as well. But eventually I made it, and with a wave of adrenaline kicking in shortly after I landed in Bordeaux, I attended to the first order of business, which was to taste through the a selection of the newly-released wines from the 2008 vintage.

Along with my colleague Thomas Matthews, I blind tasted nearly 450 reds, dry whites and Sauternes, working out of the Les Sources de Caudalie hotel near the town of Léognan. The samples were submitted by the wineries; senior tasting coordinator Alison Napjus arrived two days before me to catalog the samples and prepare the tasting flights. It took six days of tasting to work through the wines, using our normal blind tasting procedures, along with ringers and benchmarks to ensure consistency and a level playing field for all the wines. It was easily the most intensive tasting I've done—exhilarating and exhausting at the same time. You can read the first batch of reviews in the upcoming Dec. 15 edition of our weekly Insider newsletter, available only to WineSpectator.com subscribers. A full tasting report will appear in the magazine in spring 2011.

In general, 2008 is a vintage that has received little fanfare; a difficult growing season saved by some good weather right at the end resulted in one of the latest harvests on record as ripening was slow to come. Producers had to get yields down to ensure ripening and then perform rigorous selections both in the vineyards and the winery to ensure quality. The result is a very good, though rather heterogeneous vintage. Choose carefully and you'll be rewarded with wines that will benefit from a decade of cellaring, though not much more. Prices are also low, in some cases lower than the 2007s, which by most accounts is an inferior vintage, so there are some buying opportunities.

With the heavy lifting of the tasting done though, it was time to head out for some visits. I was curious to see how my deeply ingrained Rhône culture would fare in the flatter expanse of Bordeaux. The Rhône is a valley—in the north a narrow spine, a bit wider in the south. But it's easy to navigate. Vignerons are often clustered in small towns, making it easy to hop from one to another, and there's a warmth and style of hospitality there that I adore.

For my first official trip here to Bordeaux, I admittedly am a touch leery of the region's more formal personality. Owners aren't necessarily the ones making the wines. Visits tend to be in tasting rooms rather than cellars. Visits through the vineyards aren't as de rigueur. Most folks wear ties (and I'm a jeans and t-shirt guy).

But ultimately it's about the wine in the bottle and how the grape expresses its origin, whether that's a small lavender-edged field of large rolled stones or a large, gently sloping plateau of gravel deposits from a retreated riverbed. I keep telling myself that I need to focus more on that, though I can't help but use my experience in the Rhône as a barometer for Bordeaux wine culture.

So with that in mind, I made my first stop with Jean-Philippe Delmas at Château Haut-Brion to taste the 2009s. Delmas, just 41, follows in his father's footsteps in running these two estates. His father started here in '61 before moving on in '04 (and he now consults at Château Montrose in St.-Estèphe).

Both Château Haut-Brion and its sister property, Château La Mission Haut-Brion, sit like islands, wedged in the midst of the town of Pessac, a sprawling, suburban area with a bustling college campus. It reminded me a bit of Cousiño-Macul and Viña Quebrada de Macul in Chile's Maipo Valley, two wineries trying to hold out against the inevitable encroachment of Santiago's urban sprawl. The walls here are a bit higher though, and I suspect Haut-Brion and La Miss will continue on easily enough.

Though they are literally across the road from each other, technically Château Haut-Brion is in the town of Pessac while La Mission sits in Talence. They each have their respective town's water tower located in the middle of their vineyards, perhaps a small price to pay for not having to turn their terroir into parking lots or houses.

There are some changes going on here, as Delmas streamlines the labels and renames the second wines from each château. La Clarté is the new second label for the white wine, sourcing declassified fruit from both Haut-Brion and La Mission Haut-Brion; Le Clarence de Haut-Brion is now the second label for Haut-Brion, replacing the former Bahans Haut-Brion label. A third wine has also been added: the Clarendelle Rouge is a generic Bordeaux bottling which sources juice that doesn't make the cut for the second wines, as well from purchased fruit around the region.

While Delmas ferments all the estate's parcels separately, the selection for the grand vin and second wines are made in the winery, as opposed to in the vineyard.

"We taste lots both blind and not blind and generally we find the same lots will make one wine or the other, but all the lots have a chance to compete for the grand vin," said Delmas, 41.

The La Chapelle de La Mission Haut-Brion Pessac-Léognan 2009 is very grapey and primal right now, with packed red licorice and floral notes, but an overtly toasty edge that has yet to be fully absorbed. In contrast, the Château La Mission Haut-Brion Pessac-Léognan 2009 is showing its tarry, sappy, kirsch-driven spine with more clarity and focus, along with super vibrant anise and violet notes that drive through the powerful finish.

Selections here tend to be severe—typically La Mission's grand vin sees just 40 percent of the estate's production, Haut-Brion around 35 percent. But in '09, with the strength of the vintage, La Mission drew on 50 percent of the estate's production, Haut-Brion an ample 57 percent.

The Le Clarence de Haut-Brion Pessac-Léognan 2009 is easily outstanding, with grippy, dense tar, anise and mulled currant fruit. The Château Haut-Brion Pessac-Léognan 2009 is all velvet though, with lush purple, blue and black fruit aromas and flavors, a dense, fully-embedded tarry spine and a tremendously long finish.

The white wines here are equally compelling, among the more longer-lived dry whites in the region. They also sport among the highest percentages of Sémillon in their blends, 40 to 60 percent, when most of Bordeaux uses 20 percent at most. And since the heat-ravaged vintage of '03, when harvest here started on Aug. 13, the grapes are now transported in refrigerated trucks from the vineyards to the winery, to ensure freshness. It's another example of the painstaking (and cost-inducing) detail that some châteaus are able to employ as they aim for quality, even if it's for a just-in-case scenario.

[Note: For more on the Dillon family's history with Haut-Brion, see my colleague's Mitch Frank's profile in the Dec. 15 issue.]

All the whites here are vinified in oak (with varying percentages of new wood) with the malolactic fermentation then blocked as well. The La Clarté de Haut-Brion Pessac-Léognan White 2009 is brisk and lively, with lots of lemon verbena, green fig and mineral notes. The Château La Mission Haut-Brion Pessac-Léognan White 2009 is more precise, with clear verbena, white peach, paraffin and blanched almond notes that are well-delineated already, and a super long finish. The Château Haut-Brion Pessac-Léognan White 2009 takes on a creamier profile, with more green fig, almond and crème fraîche notes. It's a stunning wine in the making that should easily last for 15 years.

It was a fitting way to start my visits—at a first-growth château run by a smart, engaging young director who sets the quality bar high, getting me quickly calibrated for the rest of my time here.

And while I haven't seen any bécasses or truffles on the menus around Bordeaux, the magret de canard, foie gras and côte de bœuf ain't bad. I think I may find something to like here …

[You can now follow James Molesworth on Twitter, at http://twitter.com/jmolesworth1.]

Brad Kanipe
GA —  December 10, 2010 5:49pm ET
So Thomas decided to accompany the newbie on his first Bdx tasting did he? Just to make sure all goes smoothly I'm sure. :)

As always, I enjoyed reading your writing.
Troy Peterson
Burbank, CA —  December 10, 2010 7:43pm ET
With the controversy still so fresh, I would be somewhat apprehensive about the big shoes I was about to fill. However, I think there was a rousing online vote of confidence in you this summer and we're all looking forward to your reviews from the area.

I am worried about the amount of time the magazine is demanding of you, and how this will necessarily take away from your family life. If Marvin is reading this he better make *bleeping* sure that he gives you extra vacation time and a good chunk of Mr. Suckling's salary to make it all worthwhile.
Karl Mark
Geneva, IL. —  December 10, 2010 9:51pm ET
As always, I'm looking forward to reading your blog and tasting notes for the region. I hope you receive a warm welcome at each Chateaux, and I'm excited to hear what you think of the 2008 vintage.
James Molesworth
Senior Editor, Wine Spectator —  December 11, 2010 2:54am ET
Brad: probably not a bad idea to give me a chaperone ;-)... Besides, Tom has twice as much time as me at the magazine and he's lived in Bordeaux - a better human GPS I could not have!
Hans Vinding-diers
Patagonia —  December 11, 2010 9:27am ET
All the best in this new chapter James, hope that Bx will treat you well, anyway the wines should.
Miguel Lecuona
Austin, TX —  December 11, 2010 12:43pm ET
Starting at Haut Brion is definitely the way to go with their range and depth of excellence in both red and white. A very high bar that will stand up to most anything else on your schedule. No one will fault you if after the fortnight your HB tasting proves to be among the very best.

Don't forget to add ceppes to your menu. Lion d'or on the Left, and L'Envers du Decor on the Right are easy stops to make, too. And there's a great chocolate shop next to the Regent -- you will find much to appease your daughters this Christmas. Safe travels!
Jeremiah Morehouse
Sacramento CA —  December 12, 2010 4:49pm ET
Hi there James. Im a Sommelier from California living and studying in Italy. I am headed to Bordeaux for the Christmas holiday. Can you recommend some good wine bars or local restaurants in either Bordeaux proper or St Emilion. Have fun tasting!
Morgan Dawson
Rochester, NY —  December 12, 2010 6:51pm ET
I have learned more about HB terroir in just this from-the-road blog post than I ever did from Mr. Suckling. I remain confused as to why anyone who reads WS would think this change in coverage is anything but a major step up. We now have a Bordeaux writer who cares about sense of place, soil, and value wines.

James and Thomas - Cheers and thanks for the outstanding coverage.

Evan Dawson
Finger Lakes, NY
Steve Dow
Beavercreek, OH —  December 12, 2010 8:53pm ET
Seriously? You think Mr. Suckling doesn't care about "place, soil, and wine values?" I suggest Mr. Dawson should start reading 26 or so years of archives from WS. Get real...It's a change, so of course it will be different. A step in a different direction, but not necessarily up or down.
Morgan Dawson
Rochester, NY —  December 13, 2010 3:12pm ET
Steve -

Yes, seriously. Mr. Suckling recently said that he is much more interested in a wine's texture. I found that shocking; others might not find that to be a big deal. Mr. Suckling writes tasting notes that extol the virtues of oak in its many flavors; a 98-point Tuscan wine had seven descriptors, five of which were about the oak. He is unconcerned with the homogenization happening in the wine world. That's fine; it's just not my speed.

The archives make perfectly clear which writers are interested in really digging into the earth and telling the story of why places can be special. You'll notice in Mr. Suckling's new videos on his site, he's spending almost all of his time in the winery lab or the management's office, and he's praising the wines without any discussion of uniqueness or place.

Mr. Molesworth, on the other hand, writes almost incessantly about place. What is the character of the vineyard? What does it look like? How is it sloped, drained, composed under the surface? What does the vigneron think about these characteristics? How old are the vines? How do these factors impact the wine?

I stress that my preference is not everyone's preference. We don't all prefer the same wines, nor do we prefer the same style of coverage.

Evan Dawson
Finger Lakes, NY
Andrew J Walter
Sacramento, CA —  December 13, 2010 3:19pm ET
I would like to 2nd Morgans comment -- although not to say the JS did not care, know or write about "place, soil and wine values" (I actually enjoyed his blogs immensely almost to the point of envy -- mostly by his descriptions of his rockstar lifestyle). But, I found his palate to not be in conjunction with mine, routinely finding his reccomendations of both Bordeaux and Italy to not be to my liking. Plus, he gave way too may 100s and 99s. On the other hand, I have found JMs scores and reccomendations regarding Chile, Argentina, the Rhone, and "other US" to be very helpful--making innumerable purchase decisions which have been excellent additions to my cellar. Maybe now I'll be able to navigate the Bordeaux waters and find wines from there that I actually like on a more consistent basis.
James Molesworth
Senior Editor, Wine Spectator —  December 13, 2010 4:42pm ET
Jeremiah: Give me a little more time to 'research' that topic fully. You can start with La Tupina (country style, big portions, everything grilled over open flame) in Bordeaux, as well as L'Estaquade (modern, hip, fish-based cuisine)...then in St.-Emilion, there's Hotellerie de Plaisance (high end) and L'Envers du Décor (wine bar/bistro)...I'll try and get something a bit more formal written up when I finish with this trip...
James Molesworth
Senior Editor, Wine Spectator —  December 13, 2010 4:44pm ET
Thanks for the votes of confidence folks, as well as the appreciation of my approach. I wish my former colleague all the best - if he can excite people about wine doing it his way, then more power to him. There's plenty of room for opinion in the wine world - diversity among wine writers, just like diversity among wines, right?
Jeremiah Morehouse
Sacramento CA —  December 13, 2010 6:30pm ET
James- thanks for all the great recommendations. I am following in your footsteps and will be in Bordeaux next week. I have Chateau Palmer, La Mission Haut Brion, Smith Haut Lafitte, and Figeac on my agenda so far. Keep up the good work and good writings, keep inspiring young motivated Sommeliers like me!

Andrew, what part of Sacramento? I am living in Tuscany now, but I am a Land Park guy myself.

Would you like to comment? Want to join or start a discussion?

Become a WineSpectator.com member and you can!
To protect the quality of our conversations, only members may submit comments. Member benefits include access to more than 315,000 reviews in our Wine Ratings Search; a first look at ratings in our Insider, Advance and Tasting Highlights; Value Wines; the Personal Wine List/My Cellar tool, hundreds of wine-friendly recipes and more.

WineRatings+ app: Download now for 340,000+ ratings.