I saw a wine critic tricked into giving different reviews for the same wine. What's your take?

Ask Dr Vinny

Hello there! I'm Dr. Vinifera, but you can call me Vinny. Ask me your toughest wine questions, from the fine points of etiquette to the science of winemaking. And don't worry, I'm no wine snob—you can also ask me those "dumb questions" you're too embarrased to ask your wine geek friends! I hope you find my answers educational, empowering and even amusing. And don't forget to check out my most asked questions and my full archives for all my Q&A classics.

Dear Dr. Vinny,

I saw a show where professional wine tasters were given five glasses of the same wine to review. Not one said, "These all taste similar." What's your take?

—Jerry, Minneapolis, Minn.

Dear Jerry,

There are plenty of ways to play a trick on a wine lover. I’ve heard about the ones where cheap wines are served from expensive bottles (or vice-versa), or red food coloring added to white wines. And yes, the old “same wine in multiple glasses” deception is another "classic."

In addition to being mean-spirited, I’m not really sure what the point of these deceptions is. I don’t think wine tasting should be treated as a parlor game, and wine tasters don't claim to be infallible machines.

I admire professional wine tasters for applying their years of experience and tasting through tens of thousands of wines to give some context to what’s in the glass in front of them. I think Wine Spectator’s method of blind tasting is particularly useful, since it eliminates price- and prestige-based biases. While drinking wine should be fun, there’s a lot of concentration and work that goes into reviewing wine, assessing and describing dozens at a time. It can be a very humbling experience. When I have five wines in front of me, I assume they are different, and do my best to describe them individually. I might fall for the same trick, but I don’t think that takes away from my passion for wine or my skill for describing it.

—Dr. Vinny

Blind Tasting Ask Dr. Vinny

More In Dr. Vinny

What does “cloying” mean in reference to wine?

Wine Spectator's expert Dr. Vinny explains what happens when sweetness goes too far.

Jul 15, 2019

How should I decant a double-magnum of a 20-year-old wine?

Wine Spectator's expert Dr. Vinny offers tips on decanting large-format wine bottles.

Jul 12, 2019

Are there different strategies to preserving leftover still vs. sparkling wine?

Wine Spectator's expert Dr. Vinny explains the science behind keeping still and sparkling …

Jul 10, 2019

What sound does a cork make?

Wine Spectator's expert Dr. Vinny talks popping corks.

Jul 8, 2019

Can I bring wine on a plane?

Wine Spectator's expert Dr. Vinny explains some of the many travel restrictions on taking …

Jul 5, 2019

What does it mean if a wine has “dry tannins”?

Wine Spectator's expert Dr. Vinny explains what tannins are and how they can be perceived …

Jul 3, 2019
WineRatings+

WineRatings+

Xvalues

Xvalues

Restaurant Search

Restaurant Search