Gotham Bar & Grill Unveils Revamp, Larger Wine List

Exciting changes came with chef Victoria Blamey's arrival. Plus, Esca reopens, and Jockey Hollow in New Jersey hires new executive chef

Gotham Bar & Grill Unveils Revamp, Larger Wine List
Victoria Blamey's resume includes Chumley's, Corton and Il Buco Alimentari. (Courtesy of Gotham Bar & Grill)
Sep 12, 2019

New York's Gotham Bar & Grill, a Wine Spectator Best of Award of Excellence winner, reopened Sept. 4 after a brief closure last month. It now sports an expanded wine list and the first menu from new chef Victoria Blamey, who took over in July. Originally opened in 1984, the restaurant has long been a Manhattan institution for American cuisine, but Blamey's dishes bring a contemporary edge to the classics. Main courses include tilefish with Peruvian uni, lamb collar with pickled fairytale eggplant, and dry-aged steaks.

Wine director Josh Lit has grown the number of wine selections by about 400 in the past few months, bringing the total to 1,800 labels, with a few hundred more to come. He is also leaning more into German and Austrian white wines to complement lighter additions such as pickled oysters, yellowtail crudo and scallop ceviche.

As Lit continues to expand, covering a broad range of price points is his biggest priority. "That's been my No. 1 goal since day one," Lit told Wine Spectator. "For there to be a bottle of wine for everybody, and to always have value."

He's also added a section at the back of the list called "Vin Pur, Vino Puro," highlighting more than 100 biodynamic, minimal-sulfur or low-intervention wines. It's all part of the overarching plan to put a fresh spin on the decades-old restaurant.

"It's a really exciting time for Gotham," Lit said. "We're really looking forward to welcoming new guests as well as guests who have been coming here for the past 30-plus years."—J.H.

Esca Reopens Under New Direction and with Brand-New Wine List

On Sept. 9, chef Dave Pasternack and restaurateur Victor Rallo reopened New York Italian seafood restaurant Esca, with a new look and richer food and beverage selections. The duo also owns Award of Excellence winners Barca and Surf on Staten Island.

Pasternack has been the executive chef of Esca since its opening in 2000, but he bought the restaurant in May with his partner, Rallo, from B&B Hospitality Group. Formerly named Batali & Bastianich, the group has been reorganizing in the wake of misconduct allegations against Mario Batali.

Rallo, who serves as Esca's wine director, is eager to expand the 400-selection wine list, which has evolved from an entirely Italian selection to cover other countries around the world. The list is still heavily Italian, with emphasis on Tuscany and northern Italian regions like Piedmont and Emilia-Romagna, but now includes picks from Napa Valley, Burgundy, Bordeaux, Spain and more.

"We continue to grow by following micro-regions and wine trends to show people new styles," Rallo told Wine Spectator. Rallo chose to create a totally new wine list, rather than building off of Esca's previous program. Several verticals from producers like Oddero and Ornellaia are available, as well as Coravin pours.—N.C.

Menu highlights from Esca follow.

Crudo tasting, oysters, salad
Jim Connolly
A tasting of crudos is available at Esca, as well as a small oyster selection.
Grilled Portuguese octopus with gigante beans and balsamic vinaigrette
Jim Connolly
Grilled Portuguese octopus with gigante beans and balsamic vinaigrette
Baked clams
Jim Connolly
Vongole al forno: baked local clams with Serrano lardo
Flat pasta noodles with shrimp and corn
Jim Connolly
Scialatielli pasta with rock shrimp, Biker Billy jalapeños and roasted corn

Jockey Hollow Bar and Kitchen Names New Chef

Last month, A.J. Capella came on board as executive chef of Best of Award of Excellence winner Jockey Hollow Bar and Kitchen in Morristown, N.J., replacing Craig Polignano. Capella was previously the chef at A Toute Heure in Cranford, and his resume also includes Grand Award winner the Pluckemin Inn in Bedminster and Award of Excellence winner the Ryland Inn in Whitehouse Station.

Now that he's settled in, he's implemented new dishes with the goal of making the cuisine even more seasonal. "Ideally the menu is ever-evolving and using as [many] local things as I possibly can," Capella told Wine Spectator. He plans to change the menu multiple times each season.

Capella is passionate about supporting local farmers and artisans, especially the younger generation. Nearly all the ingredients for Jockey Hollow's new menu items are local and sourced through Capella's personal connections with purveyors. These dishes include pan-roasted duck breast with corn four ways, and a cheese plate showcasing burrata and peaches.

According to owner and wine director Chris Cannon, the leadership change won't significantly impact the 950-selection wine list, which already carries a similar mission.

"We are still committed to sourcing and featuring small artisanal wineries that are sustainable and committed to expressing terroir clearly," Cannon said via email.—J.H.


Keep up with the latest restaurant news from our award winners: Subscribe to our free Private Guide to Dining newsletter, and follow us on Twitter at WSRestoAwards and on Instagram at wsrestaurantawards.

News New York City Restaurant Awards

You Might Also Like

West Coast Wineries Face Uncertain Future

West Coast Wineries Face Uncertain Future

Online sales are up and federal aid could help, but one report estimated $400 million in …

Apr 3, 2020
Facing Coronavirus Crisis, Restaurants Shift from Shock to Survival Mode

Facing Coronavirus Crisis, Restaurants Shift from Shock to Survival Mode

With COVID-19 upending their business models, chefs and sommeliers look for assistance …

Apr 2, 2020
Another Week in a European Lockdown

Another Week in a European Lockdown

Dealing with the roller coaster of “confinement,” drinking old vintages and wondering …

Mar 31, 2020
Social Distancing in the Cellar: German and Austrian Vintners Grapple with Coronavirus Shutdown

Social Distancing in the Cellar: German and Austrian Vintners Grapple with Coronavirus Shutdown

With tasting rooms closed for the COVID-19 crisis, wineries are dealing with slumping …

Mar 31, 2020
Spain Struggles to Respond to Coronavirus, and Its Wine Industry Suffers

Spain Struggles to Respond to Coronavirus, and Its Wine Industry Suffers

Wineries endure work restrictions and slumping sales as the nation shuts down and the …

Mar 30, 2020
Charity Wine Auctions Face Cancellations and Auction Houses Go Remote

Charity Wine Auctions Face Cancellations and Auction Houses Go Remote

Auction Napa Valley has been canceled, and other charity wine events have postponed as the …

Mar 27, 2020