The Trouble with Blind Tasting

Blindly nailing down a wine's identity is a neat trick. But should it be a job requirement?
Jul 18, 2013

If you're an American in the wine industry and are within my age range (mid-twenties to early thirties, not to put too fine a point on it), you have, or are somewhere on the path toward, a Master Sommelier diploma. That is barely an exaggeration. (Some folks pursue a Wine & Spirits Education Trust diploma, or go on to a Master of Wine, instead.) For a generation that purports to care little about what the so-called experts have to say about wine, it seems we all want to become one anyway.

"It definitely helps to have it on the résumé when it comes to scoring a great job in the wine world," said Dustin Wilson, wine director at Wine Spectator Grand Award–winning Eleven Madison Park and MS class of '11. "It's a title that earns you some automatic respect."

The numbers speak for themselves: 63 and 70 people have sat for each Master Sommelier exam this year, compared to 38 and 37 in the two 2009/2010 sessions. (Some people were returning; you can repeat a failed segment of the test twice more, then you have to retake the whole thing.) In 2012, a total of 95 people took the Advanced Sommelier test for the degree a step below, with 39 more this past April. Of the 133 total North American Master Sommeliers, 71 have earned their letters since 2005, and the first test was held stateside in 1987.

By most accounts of people in the program, the series of seminars and degrees leading up to one's MS is a fantastic immersion in wine knowledge. At $2,870 for the four course levels required to get your MS—and thousands more often spent on tasting practice—it's also a pricey test to fail, and around 90 percent do in the final stage of each session (this month's sitting of 70 hopefuls only minted one new MS). There are three segments, two of them perfectly unobjectionable. Deep knowledge of wine and spirits, along with grace under fire on the restaurant floor, should absolutely be required of, well, ideally any sommelier, but certainly one who claims mastery.

But here's the rub: You also have to blind-taste six wines in 25 minutes and "identify grape varieties, country of origin, district and appellation of origin, and vintages of the wines tasted" at a minimum of 75 percent accuracy. Even if you're a wine ace, you've played this game and lost, perhaps embarrassingly. So as you might expect, the tasting sinks plenty of sad somms. The new film Somm includes scenes when the four documentary subjects/MS candidates (Wilson is one) guess off by a mile, both in their thousands of practice hours and on the big day.

"When I first passed my theory and my service in '08, I was a hair away [in the tasting segment]," said Spago's Christopher Miller. "I had blazed through the course levels, top of the class and everything, won some competitions." During the postmortem, Miller was told, "'You were so close but we couldn't give it to you because it wasn't mastery.' I was not a master taster. That was hard to hear."

Miller had just been hired to build out the cellar of Wolfgang Puck's signature restaurant. Two years later, he earned Spago a Wine Spectator Grand Award, overseeing a list he had nearly quadrupled to 3,300 selections. He also failed the MS tasting a third time.

Yet Wilson feels that the blind tasting pulls no punches. "The wines that are used are always very representative of a classic wine from a classic region. The idea is not to trick you; while Trousseau from California can be delicious, something like that would never be a part of the test." Still, he added, "I'm sure if you asked most people what the most difficult part of the exam is, I believe tasting would be at the top of most people's list. It certainly was for me."

Why do sommeliers need to be able to identify an unknown wine anyway? Their job is to pick quality wines for their restaurant and then recommend appropriate ones to guests, not to perform parlor tricks.

But Miller defended the practical application of double-blind tasting: Since blind tasting washes out received wisdoms about how wine styles are supposed to taste, the ability to pinpoint where different wines converge and diverge helps him make recommendations to his customers. "It's the things that you screw up: If you're a trained professional who's been doing this twice a week and you keep screwing up [different styles], good chance a consumer will appreciate the fact that those are similar. When you taste a Burgundy blind and you swear it's New World Pinot Noir, then somebody comes in, and they want Burgundy but something a little bit fruitier, that's the one you go to." Mistaking similar styles is less helpful when you're sitting for the exam, of course.

The training, then, makes one a better somm, but do the letters themselves? "Let's say you're studying like an Olympian for four years and you don't make the team, you're still in pretty good shape. You didn't make the cut, or you didn't have your day, that doesn't make you any less of an athlete," Miller put it. The MS should be treated as "an accreditation that is a recognition of time spent."

"And some of these people," Miller went on, "just want to rush through." He's right: I've talked to ambitious younger pros who see programs like the MS as the fast track—perhaps the only track—to the big leagues, a grad program to hustle through more than a laurel of experience.

Therein lies the trouble as I see it. Miller, who finally passed last year, is obvious proof that you don't need an MS to practice wine, unlike passing the bar for law. His story is also proof that double-blind tasting, the grafting of wine knowledge onto sensory nubbins of the brain that still trick us in ways science doesn't understand, is rather more capricious than straight book-learnin'.

As such, achievements like the MS and MW should be considered a badge, not a barrier. Yet Wilson, who had been a sommelier at RN74, another Grand Award winner, picked up his wine director gig at Eleven Madison shortly after completing his MS; another disciple in Somm was offered a plum position at Krug the day of his success. Such evidence from wine businesses that an MS might be sine qua non for certain job offers tends to feed into the anxiety of aspiring somms, even if, as Miller put it "the perception has increased more than the reality of it."

I'd caution wine businesses to ensure it doesn't become a reality. All but requiring a certification like an MS or other wine degree, which can reward the lucky and punish the accomplished, makes a wine company look unconfident in its own ability to gauge a potential hire's qualifications or, worse, foremost interested in flashing the letters of a trophy somm. That does a disservice to the customer—and the hard work of the men and women who toil through wine school.

You can follow Ben O'Donnell on Twitter, at twitter.com/BenODonn.

Blind Tasting

You Might Also Like

Why Is the Trump Administration Punishing U.S. Wine Companies with Final Move in European Trade War?

Why Is the Trump Administration Punishing U.S. Wine Companies with Final Move in European Trade War?

The White House has placed tariffs on more French and German wines; importers and retailers …

Jan 8, 2021
Restaurants on Life Support

Restaurants on Life Support

As the pandemic surges across the U.S., hundreds of thousands of restaurants are at risk of …

Dec 10, 2020
A Punk Rock Ode to Taras Ochota

A Punk Rock Ode to Taras Ochota

The beloved Australian winemaker, who died this week, swam against the current, making …

Oct 15, 2020
Binge Drinking Is Bad. So Why Is the U.S. Government Targeting Moderate Wine Consumption?

Binge Drinking Is Bad. So Why Is the U.S. Government Targeting Moderate Wine Consumption?

Discouraging people from healthy drinking habits is not the solution for stopping alcohol …

Aug 19, 2020
A New Chapter at Krug Champagne

A New Chapter at Krug Champagne

Julie Cavil succeeds longtime winemaker and mentor Eric Lebel as the grande marque 's …

Jul 20, 2020
Dine In? Take Out? America Is Having the Wrong Pandemic Debate

Dine In? Take Out? America Is Having the Wrong Pandemic Debate

Whether you believe it's time to reopen the economy or not, diners aren't rushing back to …

May 22, 2020