Still One of the World's Most Exciting Wine Regions

2009 will not match 2005 for overall quality, but many châteaus have made their best wines ever, particularly in Margaux and St.-Estèphe
Mar 29, 2010

I have to agree with some Bordeaux wine producers. The 2009 vintage in Bordeaux may be their "best ever." I am especially impressed with some of the smaller, lesser known producers in some of the top appellations such as Margaux and St.-Estèphe. They seem to have made some wonderful rich, ripe and structured young reds, and I have written in many of their tasting notes "best ever."

However, it doesn't appear that 2009 is an across-the-board success, such as 2005 and 2000, or even 2003. The smaller appellations in no way produced consistently excellent wines. For example, I had lunch early last week with Christian Moueix, the head of the family wine merchant house of Jean-Pierre Mouiex in Liborne, and he said that he and his son, Edouard, were finding it hard to select enough 2009 wine for their house blends.

"We might taste 900 samples and we only come across 10 percent that are good enough quality to go into our house blends," he said. "Many of the small producers just didn't have the means to make good wine in 2009."

I have heard the same thing from some of Bordeaux's négociants. There seems to be a consensus with them that 2005 was much more consistent in quality in Bordeaux. I found the same in my tastings so far of more than 300 wines. Wines from the smaller appellations are clearly not as impressive as the top ones relative to what they are, but there are some very good to excellent wines in such zones as Bordeaux, Côtes de Castillon and others.

The problem is simple economics. It's become a vicious cycle. Small wine producers in lesser known appellations are not selling their wines, so they have nothing to do but drop prices in hopes of selling. The lower the price they sell their wines for, the less money they have to work with toward quality in their vineyards and cellars. They grow too many grapes, they don't tend their vines properly, they make no selection, they don't maintain their cellars, and it equates to mediocre wines.

I heard from a wine producer in St.-Emilion that 50 percent of all Bordeaux now sells for about $5 a liter. That's priced less than a liter of Evian water in some U.S. supermarkets. Apparently, 95 percent of all Bordeaux sells for less than $20 a bottle.

So when some of you start bashing Bordeaux for its high prices, maybe you should think twice. It's only about 50 or so of the top names that sell their wines for astronomical prices. And I think that for value and style, Bordeaux is still one of the most exciting wine regions in the world.

But for the moment, the eyes of the wine world are primarily on the superstars of Bordeaux. Here are my latest notes on the 2009 Red Bordeauxs.

More Bordeaux Barrel Tastings 2009

See More

Bordeaux Looks for Lessons in 2009 Futures Sales

Sep 8, 2010

Despite Record Prices, Bordeaux 2009s Are Selling

Jun 24, 2010

Bordeaux's 2009 Vintage Looks Outstanding, But Will Anyone Buy?

Jun 7, 2010

2009 White Bordeaux

Apr 8, 2010

2009 Sauternes & Barsac

Apr 7, 2010

France Bordeaux 2009 Bordeaux Barrel Tastings 2009

You Might Also Like

From the Front Lines of 2009 Bordeaux Futures

From the Front Lines of 2009 Bordeaux Futures

One of the world's top Bordeaux merchants reports record sales, beating out the 2005 en …

Jul 9, 2010
Wine Budget July 2010 to July 2011

Wine Budget July 2010 to July 2011

Thinking of my wine purchases for the next 12 months

Jul 6, 2010
Betting on Older Vintage Price Appreciation

Betting on Older Vintage Price Appreciation

The extraodinary prices for 2009 Bordeaux futures will have an influence on the price of …

Jun 28, 2010
Fast and Furious 2009 First-Growths

Fast and Furious 2009 First-Growths

Futures prices for 2009 Bordeaux first-growths are starting to be revealed

Jun 21, 2010
Making a Case for Serious Organic Winemaking

Making a Case for Serious Organic Winemaking

One of Slovenia's top winemakers talks about making organic synonymous with quality

Jun 18, 2010
Are You Anti-Flavor?

Are You Anti-Flavor?

Has the backlash against overripe jammy reds crossed over to white wines? Perhaps we are …

Jun 14, 2010