Spanish Authorities Bust Wine-Counterfeiting Ring Allegedly Producing Fake Vega Sicilia and Pingus

The culprits may have netted an estimated $1.7 million since 2014 from selling counterfeit bottles
Spanish Authorities Bust Wine-Counterfeiting Ring Allegedly Producing Fake Vega Sicilia and Pingus
Peter Sisseck's Dominio de Pingus has become an icon of Ribera del Duero. (Emanuel Berk)
Jul 31, 2018

Three years ago, Peter Sisseck of Dominio de Pingus became suspicious. A cork supplier his Ribera del Duero winery didn't normally use contacted his office. A restaurant in Galicia had placed a request for Pingus-branded corks.

"We sort of let it go," Sisseck told Wine Spectator.

But two years later, a Danish buyer complained about two seemingly fake bottles of Pingus he had purchased at auction in Belgium. When Sisseck looked into it, he found out the wine had been supplied by someone from a restaurant in Galicia. "It struck me that when we investigated the incident with the corks, it also came from a restaurant in Galicia," said Sisseck.

His suspicions sparked an investigation by Spain's Civil Guard. And last month, officers announced that they had broken up a counterfeiting ring that had been operating for four years, allegedly producing fake bottles of collectible Spanish wines, like Pingus and Bodegas Vega Sicilia. Since the probe began June 18, officers have arrested four people in connection with the allegations and are investigating four more. The suspects face charges ranging from money laundering to crimes against industrial property and public health.

When the Civil Guard first picked up the case, their sleuthing took them to a restaurant in the Galician town of A Coruña named Don Álex Multibart, where they found counterfeiting operations. Additional operations were found in Madrid and Marbella. The authorities uncovered approximately 1,800 fake Pingus and Vega Sicilia labels, computer equipment used to falsify labels, and a punching machine to print on corks. The restaurant's owner was among four of the suspects arrested.

"The route of the fake wine bottles has been traced, from falsification to distribution," Civil Guard Lieutenant Abel Marín told Wine Spectator. According to Marín, the scheme involved purchasing wine for around $20, or lesser cuvées of the targeted wineries for around $100, and relabeling them as high-end bottlings fetching between $1,600 and $2,200. Bottlings of Vega Sicilia's Valbuena series, for example, were relabeled as Unico, which is the winery's top cuvée.

The wines were sold at auctions, to private clients, and to hotels and restaurants. Marín believes the scheme brought the offenders an estimated $1.7 million in profits. "Companies have been asked to increase the security measures of their wine bottles to make counterfeiting difficult," said Marín.

Sisseck said he's pretty sure there are no more counterfeits of Pingus left on the market, and has since taken measures to more easily distinguish his bottles from fake ones.

"It is important to go through the official channels," he added. "You don’t buy a Rolex watch from somebody in Times Square, and the same goes with wine."


Stay on top of important wine stories with Wine Spectator's free Breaking News Alerts.

Crime Fraud Spain News

You Might Also Like

Team Behind Two Grand Award Winners Opens Selby's in Silicon Valley

Team Behind Two Grand Award Winners Opens Selby's in Silicon Valley

Plus, RPM Restaurants has a new pizzeria in Chicago, a fourth location of International …

Jul 18, 2019
Champagne's Nicolas Feuillatte Expands, Buying the Historic Henri Abelé House

Champagne's Nicolas Feuillatte Expands, Buying the Historic Henri Abelé House

Henri Abelé will be the first standalone brand for Feuillatte, the grower-cooperative that …

Jul 15, 2019
Will the Supreme Court's Tennessee Decision Dramatically Change the U.S. Wine Market?

Will the Supreme Court's Tennessee Decision Dramatically Change the U.S. Wine Market?

The highest court delivered a win for consumers last month. Here's how this could affect …

Jul 12, 2019
UNESCO Recognizes Prosecco Wine Areas as World Heritage Site

UNESCO Recognizes Prosecco Wine Areas as World Heritage Site

Italy's hills around Conegliano and Valdobbiadene join the U.N. list's newest additions

Jul 9, 2019
Burgundy Giant Boisset to Buy Maison Alex Gambal

Burgundy Giant Boisset to Buy Maison Alex Gambal

Famille Boisset will acquire 30 acres of Pinot Noir and Chardonnay vineyards, the Gambal …

Jul 8, 2019
Bordeaux Vintners Convicted of Fraud, but Fellow Winemakers Cry Foul

Bordeaux Vintners Convicted of Fraud, but Fellow Winemakers Cry Foul

Hervé and Régis Grandeau were found guilty of selling surplus wine, but protest that …

Jul 3, 2019
WineRatings+

WineRatings+

Xvalues

Xvalues

Restaurant Search

Restaurant Search