Report Claims Less Than 1 Percent of Corks Are Noticeably Tainted

Survey pleases the cork industry, but others dispute the findings
Aug 20, 2009

Wet dog. Old Sock. Moldy basement. It seems there's a litany of ways to describe the taste and aroma of cork taint. And, unfortunately, most wine drinkers have had plenty of chances to verify those descriptions of this common wine defect.

Yet despite still being one of the leading reasons for returned bottles, a new study suggests that cork taint now affects less than 1 percent of all wine bottles. The cork industry is of course pleased by the findings—Amorim, the Portuguese company that is the world's largest cork producer, was quick to trumpet them in a press release. Corked wine has cost the industry millions of dollars a year in business lost to alternative sealing methods.

But other scientists were quick to caution that the results were far from scientific, and that cork taint remains a major problem, despite industry efforts to reduce the rate of corked wine.

Corks are made from the bark of cork trees, and various fungi live inside the fine pores that give cork its light, springy structure. Certain conditions cause the fungi to produce various chemical compounds that can affect a wine's flavor. The most notable is 2,4,6-trichloroanisole (TCA). These compounds give the wine that musty, moldy flavor and aromas.

The cork industry has spent decades trying to eliminate TCA and its friends. When chlorine- and bromine-based pesticides sprayed on cork trees and chlorine bleaches used to wash cork planks were suspected of triggering the fungi, they were eliminated, but taint kept popping up. Now Amorim and other producers use various cleaning processes. Some test the corks with gas chromatography-mass spectrometry to detect TCA early on and reject the cork. While the industry says the methods have reduced the number of bad corks, others remain skeptical.

"It's been almost 60 years that the industry has had to fix the problem," said Christian Butzke, an enology professor at Purdue University and the author of the new study, "and now they are reasonably close to doing it."

Butzke bases his claim, which appeared in a recent issue of Vineyard and Winery Management, on his survey of the 2008 and 2009 Indy Wine Competition, one of the country's largest competitions, held in Indiana annually. Both years, 70 judges identified fewer than 1 percent of 3,300 wines they tasted as affected by cork taint.

Butzke admits that the survey did not meet the rigors of a scientific study, but others support the results. "Ten years ago, people said it was much higher. Five percent, higher, the numbers were all over the place," said Susan Ebeler, a chemist in the department of viticulture and enology at the University of California, Davis. "But I trust Dr. Butzke that the number is below 1 percent now."

The assertion runs counter to several analyses, however. A 2003 report in a French journal postulated that 5 percent to 8 percent of corks on that market were tainted. In 2005, Wine Spectator senior editor James Laube found that 7 percent of 2,800 bottles sampled during tastings that year were tainted. Laube recently reported similar findings this past year.

Yet research into the science of cork taint indicates that the two results may not be mutually exclusive. The explanation for that paradox revolves around TCA itself. According to Ron Jackson, author of Wine Science: Principles and Application, a person's ability to detect the presence of TCA varies so widely that the percentage of bottles identified as corked could swing wildly depending on who was doing the tasting.

According to Jackson, 99 percent of people can detect TCA at concentrations in the range of 200 to 300 parts per million. "But some people can detect concentrations as low as single parts per trillion," said Jackson. Unfortunately, even when TCA levels are too low to detect, they can ruin a wine—at low concentrations the chemical deadens a wine's fruity flavors and aromas.

A 2002 paper in the Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry further complicates the matter. According to that paper, human identification of cork taint did not correlate with detectable levels of TCA, calling into question tasters' ability to distinguish between cork taint and other forms of wine spoilage. So not every moldy, musty smell may result from a cork problem, even if that is where tasters lay the blame.

Jackson believes the level of cork taint may dramatically drop in a few years. Cork producers phased out chlorine pesticides in the '90s, but it takes a decade or more for the trees to regenerate their bark. Soon the entire cork harvest will be chlorine- and, hopefully, TCA-free. And as long as producers like Amorim are losing money to alternative closures, they'll continue to invest money in finding ways to clean up TCA for good.

Closures Corks Wine Flaws TCA News

You Might Also Like

The Court of Master Sommeliers Is Expelling Six Members. Is It Enough to End a Culture Many Call Toxic?

The Court of Master Sommeliers Is Expelling Six Members. Is It Enough to End a Culture Many Call Toxic?

The move comes after months of investigation of sexual harassment and assault complaints

Dec 1, 2021
Provence Winemaking Iconoclast Eloi Dürrbach Dies at 71

Provence Winemaking Iconoclast Eloi Dürrbach Dies at 71

The founder of Domaine de Trévallon did things his way, making gorgeous red wines for …

Dec 1, 2021
Burgundy's Hospices de Beaune Charity Roars Back

Burgundy's Hospices de Beaune Charity Roars Back

With a new auctioneer, the historic event sold barrels of 2021 Burgundies to raise $15.3 …

Nov 29, 2021
SND: Treasury Wine Estates Buys Frank Family Vineyards, Expanding Napa Holdings

SND: Treasury Wine Estates Buys Frank Family Vineyards, Expanding Napa Holdings

The $315 million deal further shifts the Aussie wine giant into premium brands

Nov 18, 2021
Chef Christopher Kostow’s Charter Oak Comes to Cabo

Chef Christopher Kostow’s Charter Oak Comes to Cabo

The Napa restaurant will host a two-night dinner series with wine pairings at a Mexican …

Nov 18, 2021
Instagram Live Chats: View Wine Spectator's Upcoming Schedule

Instagram Live Chats: View Wine Spectator's Upcoming Schedule

Our next two episodes feature New York restaurateur Yannick Benjamin and Champagne …

Dec 1, 2021