Advice to a Newbie

"Which wine should I like?" she asked
Jul 2, 2013

Believers in biodynamics subscribe to the concept that the moon, in addition to affecting plants, also affects when wines taste good to us. They refer to a daily calendar that identifies whether a particular moment is a root day, a fruit day, a flower day or a leaf day.

Fruit and flower days, we're told, are good, as wines will be open and aromatic. Leaf days cause wines to close up; root days are the worst, as wines will offer little or no aromatics or fruitiness.

I'll leave it to you to decide how much credulity you care to invest in this sort of thing. It's based on astrological/lunar precepts, e.g., "Leo is a fire sign, and when the moon is in the constellation of a fire sign, it is a fruit day."

I find it all a bit much, to put it politely. However, there is a power to metaphors, which have their use as a kind of evocation of qualities. I mention this because I was recently beseeched by a friend who is a wine newbie to help her better understand wine.

"I know that I should drink what I like," she said. "But how do I learn what I should like?"

Now, even I, a fellow who hardly flinches when it comes to telling others what they should think, falter at saying what someone else should like.

"You know, wine is awfully personal," I stuttered, playing for time. She wasn't having it.

"You always say that some wines are better than others, she replied. "And that that quality exists independently from mere preference. So let's get down to it," she demanded. "What should I like?"

It was then that I thought of the metaphor of root days, flower days and the like. With that in mind, I submitted that there are four types of wines: Fruit Wines, Soil Wines, Climate Wines and Creativity Wines. And that she might find her path by deciding which she prefers more.

Of course, nearly all wines are amalgams of all four elements. That acknowledged, many wines—most, even—are nevertheless decisively informed by one of these four forces. For example:

Fruit Wines. As the name suggests, these are wines where the dominant force, the trump of everything else, is fruitiness. Really, what you taste in a Fruit Wine, more than anything else, is fruit intensity.

A perfect example of a Fruit Wine is pretty much any Grenache/Garnacha wine you'd care to consider. Although producers would surely beg to differ, Grenache wines, like Labrador retrievers, more resemble each other than anything else. The intensity, even exuberance, of the fruit is such that the particularities of climate or soil or even winemaking are very nearly indiscernible.

Sure, some Grenache wines are better than others. But, really, when you drink a Grenache—and this is, ironically, even more true for a good Grenache—you're hard put to say with any certainty much about the soil in which it was grown, or even all that much about climate, especially as most Grenaches are grown in warmer sites anyway. What distinguishes one Grenache from another is the depth and intensity of fruitiness.

With Fruit Wines you rarely hear invoked such terms as "layers," "finesse," "nuance" or even "acidity." Rather, it's all about opulence, intensity, succulence and approachability.

Some wines are usually Fruit Wines unless grown in very particular locations, where they can be more accurately categorized as Soil Wines. Gamay and Zinfandel are good examples. In both cases, mostly they are classic Fruit Wines.

Yet both Gamay and Zinfandel can transmogrify into Soil Wines when grown in very particular sites, such as, for Gamay, the cru zones of Beaujolais (Morgon, Fleurie, etc.), and for Zinfandel, various extremes of soil or climate in California, such as the cool parts of Russian River Valley (think Limerick Lane Zin) and Arroyo Grande (Saucelito Canyon Vineyard), or high-elevation sites such as the so-called "ridge vineyards" of Mendocino County's Anderson Valley or Napa Valley's extraordinary Sky Vineyards on the crown of Mount Veeder.

Soil Wines. When, in a single sniff and sip, you sense that the very stuff in which the vine is rooted is infused in what you're tasting, then you've got a Soil Wine. Almost invariably, Soil Wines comes from some sort of soil extreme, e.g., a lot of shale or schist or chalk. Examples abound, such as the many Soil Wines of Germany's Mosel Valley, where Riesling transmutes shale into an unmistakable flavor expression. Ditto for Mencía in Spain's slate-rich Ribeira Sacra zone.

Famously, the same magic act is performed by Chardonnay in the extreme soil of Chablis, where, as Colette lyrically put it, "Even the unemotional chalk weeps in wine, golden tears."

No nation has a monopoly on Soil Wines, as many different sorts of "extreme" soils can express themselves. The Douro in Portugal is all about a seemingly impenetrable granite and schist (they use dynamite to create terraces and even to create holes in which to plant vines).

Santa Barbara County's Sta. Rita Hills boasts Botella clay loam, and you can taste it in the Pinot Noir grown in sites lucky enough to have this soil in abundance.

Australia's Coonawarra zone southeast of Adelaide boasts its terra rossa, which is a limestone subsoil rouged with a thin layer of iron oxide–rich topsoil. Elsewhere on that continent, the Heathcote district north of Melbourne is distinguished by a narrow spine of water-retaining Cambrian subsoil that makes all the difference in that parched place. And you can taste it.

The roll call of famous Soil Wines is both lengthy and resonant, embracing the Burgundian Pinot Noir likes of Volnay Clos des Ducs (chalk) and Musigny (limestone), among dozens of other sites in the Côte d'Or.

In Italy's Piedmont region, through the Nebbiolo grape you can taste the granitic soil of Gattinara. It comes sharply into focus when compared with the Nebbiolo wines of Barolo and Barbaresco farther south, which are sited on the chalky clay soil called marl (it was once an inland sea).

Soil Wines are arguably the most memorable of all wines and certainly among the most distinctive.

Climate Wines. While all wines are influenced by climate, a sizable number of wines are emphatically defined by their climates. This is particularly true in extremes of either hot or cool. And climate strongly determines which grape varieties are most successfully grown.

What makes some wines Climate Wines may be a matter of extreme diurnal temperature differences from day to night. Many wines from Washington state, for example, are creatures of the high desert climate of eastern Washington, where summer’s blazing daytime temperatures plunge every evening. This creates striking acidity (the nighttime coolness) and strong fruitiness (the daytime heat).

Not that far away, the wines of western Oregon's Willamette Valley are, for their part, also strongly climate-influenced. Unlike eastern Washington, the Willamette Valley has long, cool springs, lingering autumns, and a gentle moderation that both teases out and locks in the berryish qualities of Pinot Noir as well as ensures a certain tenderness and unmistakable finesse. Oregon's Pinot Noirs are more creatures of climate than of soil.

California's interior Central Valley, for its part, is all about a hot growing-season climate, just as Monterey County's Salinas Valley is mostly about ocean-influenced coolness.

Very likely more wines can legitimately be called Climate Wines than any other category. Not surprisingly, Climate Wines often converge with Fruit Wines, as the former frequently serves to encourage the latter. The difference is that not all Climate Wines are also Fruit Wines, either because it's too cool to create intense fruitiness or too warm and the fruitiness "bakes out".

Creativity Wines. This surely is the most complicated and controversial category of all. Simply put, Creativity Wines are those where a considerable amount of effort—more than the usual and essential procedures necessary to make good wine—has been expended to create a wine that is as much from the imagination of the winemaker as it is a straightforward expression of site and grape.

Various terms are applied, many of them used as a condemnation, such as "manipulated," "interventionist," and the slangy jargon used by some, "spoofulated." Adherents to the so-called "natural wine" movement abhor a variety of winemaking practices that they see as distorting.

What can be said is this: Some wines are indisputably "creative.” Winemakers can (and do) pick grapes at extreme ripeness levels for their soft, almost non-existent tannins and plush flavors, make the wine, and then reduce the high alcohol level that inevitably occurs from such sugar-rich grapes by running the wine through a high-tech machine (spinning cone, reverse osmosis, etc.) to eliminate a certain percentage of alcohol.

Whether this is desirable or unacceptable depends upon your point of view—and your palate. Many other techniques are employed to "sculpt" wine. Here again, whether the use of particular enzymes, cultured yeasts, added sugar or grape concentrate, the use of "bleeding off" or vacuum concentrators (to reduce dilution), or any number of other techniques is simply too much or an ideal advance is a matter of vexed discussion.

One thing can be said: Creativity Wine, like cosmetic surgery, runs the risk of being obvious. The issue, as is so often the case, is a matter of degree. A little can be fine, even admirable, while a lot creates a wine grotesque. At what point does a wine, à la Michael Jackson, become so distorted that it no longer reflects anything except what’s been done to it?

Finally, what did I tell my friend about what she should like?

I told her to be on guard against anything she sensed might cross the line into an obvious Creativity Wine. But beyond that, she should simply enjoy her wines, trying for the sheer fun of it to decide whether it’s a Fruit Wine, a Soil Wine or a Climate Wine in her glass—or a magnificent amalgam of all three, which might be called an Ideal Wine.


You Might Also Like

Prosecco's Identity

Prosecco's Identity

Is it an Italian thing? For most of the world, yes. Australia begs to differ

Sep 29, 2022
40 Years of Roederer Estate

40 Years of Roederer Estate

The California sparkling wine producer remains one of the best and most consistent on the …

Sep 30, 2022
Virtual Content, Real Wine: Take Two

Virtual Content, Real Wine: Take Two

After more than two years of virtual wine tastings, it's time to raise the bar on these …

Sep 30, 2022
The Chilled Reds of Summer

The Chilled Reds of Summer

Forget “room temperature” and ice those reds

Aug 2, 2022
Keeping an Open Mind on 2020

Keeping an Open Mind on 2020

All was not lost in a Napa Cabernet vintage turned upside-down by wildfires and a pandemic:…

Jul 18, 2022
A Grand Award Remembered

A Grand Award Remembered

How a covert restaurant reinspection led to great memories—and lots of Champagne

Aug 31, 2022