David Arthur looked to be one of Napa's star properties when its Cabernets debuted in the 1990s. The Elevation 1147 bottling in particular was often amazingly complex. But the wines were also inconsistent, great one year, less so the next, with Merlot and a super Tuscan-inspired cuvée Merritagio often less impressive.
Join today and get immediate access to this article, and to our entire database of more than 345,000 wine ratings. It only takes moments—but it will help you drink better all year long.