Judgment of Florence

James Suckling
Issue: October 31, 2007

I had visions of this tasting as another Judgment of Paris, but in Florence instead. The wines pitted against one another were not some of the great names of Bordeaux versus those of California, but Tuscan cult wines against Cabernets from Napa Valley.

To Continue Reading This Page, Become a WineSpectator.com Member Today!

Get a SNEAK PREVIEW of the Top 100 Wines of 2009 on Monday, Nov. 16th

PLUS:

Search over 200,000 wine ratings and tasting notes

Get FREE mobile access

Consult our editors' blogs

Find widely available wines and good values

Get e-newsletters with ADVANCE ratings


Log In If You're Already a WineSpectator.com Member

Please login using your email address and password for WineSpectator.com




Forgot Password?

By clicking "Log in" you agree to the Terms and Conditions of Wine Spectator Online

MEMBER LOGIN                NOT A MEMBER?

= available only to members



Forgot Password?   

  • Get a SNEAK PREVIEW of the Top 100 Wines of 2009
  • Search wines in every price range
  • Get mobile access
  • Read editors' blogs for expert advice
  • Keep track of your favorite wines

Free Email Newsletters

Sips & Tips | Wine & Healthy Living | Video Theater
Collecting & Auctions | New at Wine Spectator

» View samples
» Or sign up now!
» Manage my newsletter preferences