Log In / Join Now

An Australian One-Stop Winery: Innocent Bystander

Yarra Valley favorite shows what a tasting room can be
Photo by: David Yellen

Posted: May 15, 2014 3:37pm ET

Healesville, a Yarra Valley town an hour's drive from Melbourne, attracted me not only for the wines, but also a visit to Innocent Bystander, where Phil Sexton makes Pinot Noirs and Chardonnays in the steely style currently in vogue. His Giant Steps label, which focuses on single-vineyard Yarra Valley wines, often rates among my leaders for Chardonnay.

More than the wines intrigued me. The modern building is an architectural award winner for its angled placement, green certifications and distinctive long swaths of wooden slats on the exterior. The 70,000-case cellar door (Aussie talk for tasting room) also bakes artisan bread, makes pizza, sells cheese and pulls some of the better espresso in the neighborhood. Dipping into the lunch menu is rewarding.

Sexton came to wine via beer. He started Little Creatures, a favorite of Aussie hopheads, in Perth (Western Australia) and also makes White Rabbit, a Belgian-style ale, in a brewery adjacent to the winery in Healesville. He got into wine by founding Devil's Lair, the Margaret River winery now owned by Treasury Wine Estates.

Devil's Lair Chardonnays turned my head for their heady richness and expressiveness. Giant Steps is the polar opposite. Tasting mini verticals of two single-vineyard wines, I was struck by the tight structure and nerve of the Tarraford Vineyard bottling, showing green guava and passion fruit in 2010, grapefruit and melon in 2008, a hint of preserved lemon in 2005. Sexton Vineyard displayed more openness, with spice to the grapefruit and mineral in 2012, a hint of smoke in 2009.

"We never add acidity," said longtime winemaker Steve Flamsteed. "We try to grab the fruit in that citrus-melon zone. When it goes into white peach, yellow peach or nectarine, it's gone past it. Those end up evolving into tropical flavors, which we've seen in later-picked Yarra Chardonnays in the past."

Giant Steps reflects the best aspects of Australia's shift in style in Chardonnay toward more bracing characteristics. Too many others come off as thin, ungrateful, pouty wines. Not Giant Steps. They're worth seeking out.

Sexton and Flamsteed make another wine that lit up my eyes: Innocent Bystander Syrah, the French moniker a tipoff that it's intended to be a lighter, fresher style than what's labeled Shiraz. The 2012, tasted at the winery, struck me as taut and sleek, its 2 percent Viognier helping make it pretty. Tasted blind back in the U.S., I found it fresh and expressive, layered with delicate hints of sandalwood, black tea and mint around a lithe core of blackberry and licorice. A real deal for $20.

Dan Weis
St. Louis, MO —  May 16, 2014 9:31am ET
My daughter moved to Melbourne 3 years ago and has visited wineries from Margaret River to Hunter Valley. While we were visiting, we toured the Yarra Valley but unfortunately, our guide drove right past this winery and brewery. I hope you are including Mornington Peninsula in your travels. The Pinot Noir was a real surprise, but unfortunately, they only produce enough for domestic distbitution. Give Foxy's Hangout a go and get the tasting menu while you are there.
Ronnie Sanders
Philly —  June 5, 2014 11:03am ET
I had the pleasure of having dinner at Innocent Bystander with Phil and Steve on my last visit to Oz and you are spot on about the wines, the food, the bread and Steve and Phil. Total class act and their wines are fantastic and well worth seeking out.

Would you like to comment? Want to join or start a discussion?

Become a WineSpectator.com member and you can!
To protect the quality of our conversations, only members may submit comments. Member benefits include access to more than 315,000 reviews in our Wine Ratings Search; a first look at ratings in our Insider, Advance and Tasting Highlights; Value Wines; the Personal Wine List/My Cellar tool, hundreds of wine-friendly recipes and more.
Most Recent Posts
Mar 21, 2018
The Music of Wine
Dec 19, 2017
Wine Kludges

WineRatings+ app: Download now for 340,000+ ratings.